Cheltenham Gold Cup 2011 Preview: Trends

A Race Too Far for Denman and Kauto Star?

A Race Too Far for Denman and Kauto Star?

It may seem a bit early to be previewing the Blue Riband event at next year's Cheltenham Festival meeting, dear reader, but I have a good reason for attacking the Gold Cup so early...

You see, I'm convinced that at least three of the top four in the betting cannot possibly win the race, which means that it becomes a wide open 20/1 the field contest. Are you a little more interested now? 😉

My conviction is predicated on the fact that we are (over)due a 'changing of the guard' at the top of the staying chaser category. Two of the big three, Denman and Kauto Star, are going to be eleven on January 1st (when all horses gain a year in age). Without question, they are two of the finest National Hunt horses for a generation... but they're not getting any younger.

The other, Imperial Commander, last year's Cheltenham Gold Cup winner, will be ten years old on the first day of 2011. No spring chicken himself, despite relatively few miles on the clock.

And the fourth horse in the betting in some lists is Big Buck's. Actually it's only William Hill's greedy list, where he's a 12/1 shot. If I tell you that he's 143 currently on Betfair that tells you all you need to know. He won't run in the Gold Cup, because he's won the World Hurdle for the last two years and he'll be going for a hat-trick there. Moreover, even if he did go the chase route, he's a lousy jumper and a good stone below top class. Factor in his sulky 'on and off the bridle' running style, and 143 is much closer to his true chances!

So, where does that leave us? Well, unless you're a rabid pin-sticker, it leaves us with 20/1 the field in a lottery. But that's where the stats come in. I've done my usual number bashing, and discovered some pretty interesting nuggets. The sum total of my nuggets is that one horse has a fine Gold Cup profile at this stage... though that could certainly change before the end of the year.

Let's get down to it. I looked at nationality, odds, age, last time out performance, best seasonal performance, top official rating, TopSpeed figure, and Racing Post Rating prior to winning; and also at past Cheltenham Festival form.

And I can tell you this... most winners conform to a fairly tight profile.

I've used the last ten winners which means the last eleven years, as there was no Festival in 2001 due to foot and mouth. (What the hell did we do in March that year?!)

- All ten winners went off 15/2 or shorter in the betting. However, in the three years prior to that, the winners' odds were 16/1, 25/1 and 20/1 respectively.

- All ten winners were aged between seven and nine years old. (If you like Imperial Commander, the last 10yo to win was Cool Dawn in 1998. If you like Long Run, the last 6yo to win was Mill House in 1963! If you like either Kauto Star or Denman, the last 11yo to win was Mandarin in 1962, although What A Myth did prevail as a 12yo in 1969! 😉

- Nine out of the ten finished first or second in a Grade 1 or 2 race last time out. And seven out of ten had their final pre-Gold Cup start in December, either in the King George or the Lexus Chase. (Two of the three who had a run after December ran in and won the Aon Chase at Newbury in February).

- The last nine winners had already recorded a first or second place finish in a Grade 1 contest that season prior to winning the Cheltenham Gold Cup.

- Nine of the ten winners had had between six and twelve chase starts, and all ten had won at least four times over the big obstacles.

- All ten were officially rated 159 or higher before winning their Gold Cup. 7/10 were rated 169 or more.

- Nine out of ten had run a Topspeed figure of at least 157. This doesn't help a lot as most top class chasers should have recorded this figure or better.

- All ten winners had registered a Racing Post Rating of 167 or more.

- Perhaps most interestingly of all, nine out of the last ten Cheltenham Gold Cup winners had already finished first or second in a previous Cheltenham Festival race. The one exception was Kauto Star before his first Gold Cup win, and he'd fallen when a short priced favourite for the Arkle previously.

You can view this data in a line by line format by clicking on the image below:

Fifteen Year Trends for Cheltenham Gold Cup 2011

Fifteen Year Trends for Cheltenham Gold Cup 2011

Now that's all well and good, but what if it actually does nothing to reduce the field for this year's race? Well, thankfully, it does plenty to help us pare things to a more manageable conundrum.

Firstly, unless you're prepared to roll back more than fifty years of Gold Cups, you'll be following me in striking a line through the venerable veterans, Denman and Kauto Star. Obviously, it would be a staggering and truly tear-jerking feat if either of the old boys could grab Gold Cup glory once more. But to bet on it would be to ignore the evidence of half a century. Not for me, with my head, despite my stated weakness where my heart is concerned.

Your first 30 days for just £1

Long Run is a 25/1 shot at best, and 16's in places. He's only five right now and, despite turning six on New Year's Day, he's still got to overcome that age stat. Oh, and improve around a stone on what he's achieved so far. Not impossible, but not really a betting proposition either.

And finally, in the orange'y autumnal amber section, I've placed last year's impressive Gold Cup winner, Imperial Commander (and very talented long-term absentee, Neptune Collonges). Both of these chaps will be ten next year. Cool Dawn in 1998, Cool Ground in 1992, and Charter Party and Desert Orchid in 1988 and 1989 respectively testify that it can be done.

But no double digit winner has prevailed since 1998, and whilst I can't quite put my finger on why this is (I suspect it may be somehow tied to the emergence of more precocious French-bred's, despite their poor overall performance in the Gold Cup, Kauto Star aside), I'm loathe to pile into a ten year old attempting to win the Gold Cup.

That said, I can find very few chinks in the champ's chainmail (easy for me to say) and, granted he gets there fresh and well, he's sure to take some beating. With those caveats to the fore, I'd be perfectly happy to risk taking a slightly short price as a day of race saver... especially if my ante-post interests have shortened in the betting in the interim!

So age does for four of the top eight in the betting (I can hear the form book purists tutting and harrumphing at my dismissive comments from here!)

At this rate, we'll soon cut the field down to size, with or without form book passengers. 😉

Moving on, and the next few trends that I consider key are those surrounding Festival and seasonal form - welcome back, form book munchers! I wouldn't discard you as easily as that!

To remind ourselves of the recent evidence of some paragraphs ago, first or second in a previous Festival race seems to be very important (only the fallen favourite, Kauto Star, failed on this score prior to his first GC win). And it also seems to be key to have demonstrable Grade 1 form that sesason in the form of a win or runner up position in a Grade 1 contest.

At this stage, we'll place more emphasis on the Cheltenham Festival credential as, clearly, there is ample time for Gold Cup contenders to illustrate their top class merits in the Grade 1 races to come.

So, focusing on past Festival glories (or very near misses) leads us to closer review Punchestowns (2nd in the 2009 World Hurdle); Cooldine (won 2009 RSA Chase); Burton Port (2nd RSA Chase 2010); Somersby (2nd Arkle 2010 and also 3rd Supreme Novices 2009); Sizing Europe (won 2010 Arkle; favourite when disappointing in the 2008 Champion Hurdle); and, Mikael d'Haguenet (won 2009 Ballymore Hurdle).

Although not strictly qualifying on this point, honourable mentions in despatches go to Weird Al, who has two Cheltenham novice chase wins to his name, neither at the Festival; Planet of Sound, who was 3rd in the 2009 Arkle; and the unlucky Carruthers, who has a fourth place in both the Gold Cup this year, and the RSA Chase in 2009.

Put another, considerably more succinct, way, I'm drawing a line through What A Friend (6th in 2009 RSA Chase, pulled up in 2008 Albert Bartlett Hurdle); Joncol, who has never donned his trunks for a swim across the Irish Sea; and Pandorama for the same reason. That said, Pando is in the Hennessy, so could at least show he travels with a good performance there. (On the other hand, he's only had three races over fences so looks too inexperienced for such a tall order at the Gold Cup!)

Looking for a first or second place finish in a Grade 1 at this stage of this season is extremely premature. However, there are some that have already qualified, and all the others have to earn their ticket by running a tip top race in a tip top race. Those that have already gone 1-2 in a top class affair are: Imperial Commander, Kauto Star, and Sizing Europe (second, beaten four lengths by Kauto Star).

Sizing Europe goes for Gold Cup glory

Sizing Europe goes for Gold Cup glory

And, at this stage, there is only one horse I'm interested in. And that's Sizing Europe. There are question marks about his stamina, even though he plugged on gamely in that three mile Grade 1 at Down Royal last time on soft ground. He wouldn't have enjoyed the conditions especially, and he's certain to plummet in the betting should he win or run close in the King George (for which he's a best priced 16/1 and a general 12 and 14/1 chance).

So far, Sizing Europe has had eight chase runs, and never been out of the first three, winning five of them (including this year's Arkle, and a Grade 1 novice last Christmas).He's a nine year old next year, has run the requisite figures (with the exception of a Racing Post Rating one pound shy of the qualification mark), has already demonstrated his liking for the Festival and his ability this season, and a placed finish in the King George would surely see him cut to around a third of his current 33/1 best price quote (Victor Chandler only).

He's as short as 16's with Paddy Power, and is a general 20 and 25/1 shot.

26/11 at midday - STOP PRESS: Geegeez readers have swooped and snapped up all the 33's with VC, so general 25/1 is the best available price now. 🙂 🙁

He's still got improvement in him, which is good as he'll need to find fifteen pounds or thereabouts to beat Commander, Kauto or Denman.

Now I actually believe that those three may all prove to be regressive this season, as age catches up with them, so it may be that improvement of around ten pounds is enough. That's conjecture and has little place here, aside from attempting to add ballast to my already struck ante-post punt on Sizing Europe.

Long suffering readers will recall that I piled into this horse for the Champion Hurdle in 2008. Some of the same readers may also recall I went nowhere near him in the Arkle last year, when of course he won. Can it be third time lucky for Bisogno and Sizing Europe? 33/1 says it's worth a try...

One final point on Sizing Europe. He's likely to have entries in the Champion Chase (two miles) and the Ryanair Chase (2m5f) as well as the Gold Cup, so win only is the way forward for this - and indeed most - ante-post tickle(s).

Sizing Europe to win the Cheltenham Gold Cup?

Sizing Europe to win the Cheltenham Gold Cup?

As I say, there are others who may come into it as time passes between now and March, but there are really only three races to take special heed of: the King George on Boxing Day, the Lexus Chase on 28th December (I think), and the Aon Chase in early February. The first two are more important than the last named.

Finally, the Hennessy is shaping up to be a fantastic race this weekend, but in reality it is likely to shake up the Cheltenham Gold Cup betting far more than it actually deserves to. Apart from confirmed Newbury fanatic, Denman, the last horse to win - or even run in - the Hennessy en route to winning the Cheltenham Gold Cup in the same season was Jodami back in 1992. (He finished second that day, and the horse one place behind him, The Fellow, went on to win the following year's Gold Cup).

As the prices slash on any number of close up Hennessy runners, remember that a) it's a Grade 3 contest, and b) they're all getting a stone and a half off Denman.

If you want to see my workings out, and maybe put your own spin on the data, click the image below.

Toodlepip!

Matt

p.s. what's your take on the Gold Cup? Kauto? The Commander? Durable Denman? Or a new kid on the Hill? Leave a comment, and let us know where your money's going to be.

Gold Cup 2011 Contenders

Gold Cup 2011 Contenders

p.p.s. Here's the Excel file if you want to play around with things:
CHELTENHAM GOLD CUP 2011 TRENDS EXCEL

p.p.p.s. This is my current ante-post portfolio in case you're interested...

Geegeez Ante Post portfolio, 24th Nov 2010

Geegeez Ante Post portfolio, 24th Nov 2010

Your first 30 days for just £1
8 replies
  1. Duncan says:

    Matt
    Another soundly reasoned article
    Thanks

    You may need to check the Excel Link as I get a zip file containing a load of xml files ??

    Duncan

    • Matt Bisogno says:

      Thanks Duncan – I’ll take a look at that. Glad you liked the article. I do worry about Sizing Europe’s stamina, but at the same time he remains the most likely candidate, at this stage at least.

      Matt

      • Matt Bisogno says:

        You were spot on Duncan – I’ve amended now, and it should download fine. 🙂
        Matt

  2. WILF RAY says:

    Sorry Matt, you are way off target. WIERD AL will do for me.Good luck anyway.
    Wilf.

    • Matt Bisogno says:

      No problem Wilf. Al will have to win, and win well, tomorrow to have much chance in the Gold Cup. But of course, like I said, expect all of the first three home to shrink markedly in the betting for March after the race.

      I really like Weird Al, but reckon he’ll have a better chance next year than this. He also has to prove he stays 3m3f, as his only run (and win) beyond three miles was in an absolute dawdle of a race (43 seconds slower than standard) at Wetherby, where there were only four runners.

      As I say, I like the horse, but he has a hell of a lot to prove to be considered a potential Gold Cup winner this season. He might do that of course, but at the price he’s not for me.

      Best,
      Matt

  3. john parsons says:

    If you’d read Nick Mordin’s article in the Racing Post about 10 days ago, you would be inclined to back Sizing Europe for the King George. In the article the writer stated that Sizing Europe was a deliberate jumper and that he would be much better suited to a flat track like Kempton than Down Royal where he finished second to Kauto. So I tend to agree with you, but I’m happy with the 200 quid each way I’ve had on him for the King George at 16s.. I think Planet of Sound is a good each way bet for the Gold Cup.

    • Matt Bisogno says:

      Very interesting John. I’ll be hoping as much as you that SE can do the biz at Kempton. Certainly, Kauto won’t run away with it and, considering SE’s Cheltenham form, he’s well up to the fences there too. Stamina remains the uncertainty (as well as that touch of class perhaps as well).

      Matt

  4. SEAN says:

    I have a fancy for COOLDINE for the 2011 Gold Cup – RSA winner over 3m+ as a 7yo, 5th in 2010 GC and a year older and stronger this time around – KAUTO and DENMAN will be 11yo’s and may have had their day.

Comments are closed.