Come on Paul, make a stand, writes Tony Stafford. Persuade owner Colm Donlon to pay the £18,000 supplementary fee and put Tutti Quanti in next month’s Champion Hurdle! In some ways the parallels are obvious. On February 8th 1997, Make A Stand, ridden by A P McCoy made all to win the Tote Gold Trophy in a one-two for the Martin Pipe stable, beating stablemate Hamilton Silk by nine lengths, dominating his 17 opponents with ease.
He carried 11st7lb off a mark of 140, which included a 4lb penalty for his previous success at Kempton in the Lanzarote Handicap Hurdle, then a two-mile race rather than its five furlongs longer identity these days. The following month he won the Champion Hurdle in similar fashion.
Tutti Quanti on Saturday, like Make A Stand 29 years earlier, was immediately taken to the front by Harry Cobden, accompanied by a couple of over-optimistic opponents. The trio was quickly clear of the rest of the 15-runner field. Then by the turn into the straight, the die was already cast. Moving smoothly, Tutti Quanti, despite 12st top weight for his mark of 138, was the only horse not already struggling in the very testing ground.
His advantage began inexorably to extend from Wellington Arch, who had taken second place by that point. Then up the long home straight, seemingly after little effort from the horse and certainly minimal energy from his rider, he had that gallant pursuer 15 lengths adrift by the line. I reckon it could have been nearer 25 lengths had Harry wished.
Astonishingly, the second was another 18 lengths clear of a trio that fought a slow-motion tussle for the honour of third (and not inconsiderable prize of £18k). It went to 7lb claiming amateur Miss Heidi Palin on 33/1 shot Faivoir, trained by Dan Skelton. Skelton also provided the race favourite, heavily backed Let It Rain, but she pulled up.
We were still finding difficulty at the time of Make A Stand’s success in calling the race anything other than the “Schweppes”, even though the Tote had taken over its sponsorship a decade earlier in 1986. Some, including me, hark back to the old days far too frequently. Sir Rupert Mackeson, the veteran bookseller, even referred to “Schweppes weekend” in his email on Saturday morning, 40 years after the soft drinks firm had abandoned ship!
The race was instigated in 1963 as one of the earlier lucrative commercial race sponsorships in UK racing and was staged once at Aintree before moving to its subsequent home of Newbury. It was quickly made famous and as much notorious through the exploits of the Findon, Sussex-based master trainer and former wartime Commando, Captain Ryan Price.
Ho won the first two with Rosyth, whose second success resulted in a six-week ban for his trainer following a dodgy prep run for his horse. Le Vermontois’ triumph involved no such scandal.
On that February Saturday in 1967, I was walking up (or was it down?) a hill in Northumberland with a transistor radio glued to my ear. I was there to cover the FA Amateur Cup quarter final between Whitley Bay and Walthamstow Avenue - the event and the Avenue both long sadly confined to the dustbin of history. We won, by the way, but were knocked out in the semi-final.
A couple of the local press guys – I worked that year at the Walthamstow Guardian, my first job on a newspaper - travelled in the team coach to their away matches. Following home games at Gander Green Lane, we routinely got to join the players for dinner in Jim Gill’s restaurant at the bottom of Walthamstow High Street.
I listened as Hill House easily made it four wins from the first five runnings of the race for Price. Even with the questionable acoustics, the boos that rained down from the stands could be clearly heard even above Peter Bromley’s spirited commentary.
Hill House had refused to race at Kempton two weeks before the big day and then was only fourth at Sandown the previous weekend, most professionals reckoning he had a typical “easy”. In the Schweppes, Hill House duly strode clear to win by 12 lengths, returning to a crescendo of booing. Price’s wife Dorothy vowed never to go racing again – and never did.
A subsequent inquiry found that Hill House had tested positive for cortisone, a banned substance but then further tests found evidence he manufactured his own cortisone. The matter ended there, but not the stigma to Captain Price.
Normal service resumed the following year when Persian War, a five-year-old trained in Wales by Colin Davies, ridden by Jimmy Uttley and owned by bookmaker Henry Alper, set a weight-carrying record of 11st13lb. The historians had not immediately realised that near 60-year record had finally been expunged from the books by Tutti Quanti’s winning under 12st on Saturday.
Persian War went on to win the Champion Hurdle that March and twice more before being relegated to second place behind Bula, another outstanding champion of that vintage era. Bula was trained by Fred Winter.
Persian War had been a slowcoach on the flat but was transformed by jumping when his stamina was a major contributor to his success. Make A Stand, like Persian War, started on the flat. He was a son of Master Willie and was in training with Henry Candy.
Make A Stand won a 23-runner nursery at Newmarket off 74, but by the time he turned up for a claiming race at Leicester in August the following summer, his mark had declined to 52 – the handicappers were a little more understanding in those days. You’d need to run 30 times now rather than Make A Stand’s six to drop that far! He did win that 1m4f race with ease, and the next time he ran was for Pipe, two unsuccessful flat-race outings finishing his three-year-old activity. I wanted to check the Racing Post’s analysis for the Leicester claimer, but 32 years on, we’re still waiting!
Make A Stand was fast away the following year when initially put to hurdles, winning three in a row, before Martin also exploited his still modest flat mark. By the time he got to the Tote Gold Trophy, he was the veteran of 27 races and came to Newbury fresh from three consecutive handicap hurdles victories at Sandown, Ascot and Kempton. There was never much doubt that number four would be in the bag. It wasn’t!
In the Champion Hurdle he beat a field that included the previous year’s winner Collier Bay, and in a hint of what was to come, a youthful Aidan O’Brien sent out the 33/1 runner-up Theatreworld. Aidan was to win the next three championships with the peerless Istabraq.
Tutti Quanti was hardly coming out from left field on Saturday. He had comfortably won the Gerry Feilden Hurdle over the same course and distance in November and on the morning of the race, Nicholls told Cobden he was extremely confident. He was the 100/30 second-favourite.
Why then, after such an overwhelming success in one of the most competitive (usually) handicap hurdles of the season, shouldn’t he go down the Persian War and Make A Stand route?
For an investment of £18k, the potential win prize of £252,315 represents around 14/1 for his money – albeit the owner’s portion is more like 70 per cent. Still, you’d be making a lot of people, including trainer, jockey and stable staff, happy if it happened; and Donlon picked up a healthy £87k on Saturday, so he starts from a position of strength.
They have until March 4, six days before the race to decide and the weather in the meantime will be a major factor in the decision. I remember in 1986 desperately wanting rain for a horse of mine that was fancied for the Triumph Hurdle, and the whole previous six weeks were cold and dry. Could be the same over the next three weeks, though unlikely if recent weather is to go by, but as I say, Colm doesn’t need to decide yet.
The most significant performance of the week, apart from Tutti Quanti, was the win of Lulamba in the Game Spirit Chase. Having effectively had only one and a half previous runs over fences (low sun ruled out six fences on debut), Nicky Henderson’s novice was far too good for more experienced chasers at Newbury. I think he can emulate Sprinter Sacre and Altior and go on to win the Arkle at Cheltenham next month.
- TS