Monday Musings: Woof No More

Lots of us thought he was a dog! As the series of second places built up to four, many people including me were quick to brand the Francis-Henri Graffard-trained four-year-old Calandagan ungenuine – at the very least a gelding that perhaps didn’t try as hard as he should, writes Tony Stafford.

For a while his biggest claim to fame was that as a gelding, he wasn’t qualified to run in his home country’s greatest race, the Prix de l’Arc de Triomphe. Graffard and regular stable jockey Mickael Barzalona won that this year anyway with the year-younger Daryz, like Calandagan a home-bred from the late Aga Khan’s studs.

Their owner died earlier this year, so missed one of the most glorious chapters of his lifetime as an owner-breeder. Calandagan’s rise to being officially the top racehorse in the world gained a fitting gilding to that accolade when he became the first overseas winner of the Japan Cup for 20 years at Tokyo racecourse yesterday.

The last one was Luca Cumani-trained and Frankie Dettori-ridden Alkaased, whose winning time of 2 minutes 22.1 seconds in 2005 was then the record time for the race. That succumbed only once in the intervening years, to the great Almond Eye, but her figure was trimmed again as Calandagan rallied to wrest victory close to the line from the home-trained favourite Masquerade Ball in the 17-runner affair.

His time for the 12 furlongs was 2 minutes 20.3 seconds, more than three seconds faster than Found recorded in the quickest-ever Arc for the Aidan O’Brien/Coolmore team in 2016. Just think of it, yesterday’s winner averaged fewer than 12 seconds per furlong (11.67 to be precise) over a mile-and-a-half: not much below sprinting pace!

Thus, after that quartet of second places, it is now four Group One victories in a row - and how - for Calandagan, following the Grand Prix de Saint-Cloud in June; the King George and Queen Elizabeth Stakes at Ascot in July; and the Champion Stakes, easily from Ombudsman, again at Ascot in October. Some hound!

https://youtu.be/L5sUW79JlQo?si=hvrngEGBpFCWBQZ0

It took a battling performance from the winner, and the exciting thing for international racing is that the son of Gleneagles – whose 2026 fee has remained at €20k for the forthcoming season - will almost certainly remain in training with the expectation of boosting his already lavish earnings figure.

Yesterday’s version carried a first prize of £2.6 million, but under the race conditions, the King George was one of several incentivised qualifying races which brought an invitation to the race and a £2.3 million bonus for any horse that followed by winning the Japan Cup.

No doubt that possibility had been insured and equally the fact that it had been 20 years since an overseas horse had won, the unlikely eventuality had been largely discounted. Even though he was the best horse in the world on ratings Calandagan was only second best in the market at 11/4. He won’t be as big as that for any race that Graffard chooses to point him at any time soon.

For a Coolmore team still having to adjust to losing their number one Galileo replacement, Wootton Bassett, who died in the early autumn while on his off-season stint in Australia, Gleneagles’ son’s exploits are a reminder that Coolmore is far from a one-sire outfit.

They are almost embarrassingly well-stocked with top-class new sires that entered stud this year and several other high-class performers from the 2025 Classic season that have followed them on.

Mickael Barzalona had to overcome his compatriot Christophe-Patrice Lemaire on the favourite and the pair passed the finish two and a half lengths ahead of third-placed Danon Decile. Lemaire has been riding in the biggest races in Japan combined with his domestic duties for many years and has won the Cup four times, starting with Vodka (2009).

He won twice on Almond Eye (2018, in that record time, and 2020) and also partnered the exceptional Japanese champion Equinox two years ago. Ryan Moore and Oisin Murphy are other top riders to have won the race in recent years, but the last French-trained horse to win was Le Glorieux way back in 1987.

Barzalona has come a long way from that day at the Derby when he started celebrating before passing the line to win for Andre Fabre on Pour Moi in the Michael Tabor colours. That was probably just youthful exuberance, and he has proved himself a top-flight international pilot with increasing regularity since, like a slow-maturing French red wine.

A year after Pour Moi, Brian Meehan booked Barzalona to ride Ray Tooth’s Catfish in the Vodafone Dash on Derby Day and the rather headstrong filly probably lost all chance when her saddle slipped as they left the stalls. Far from making her usual fast start, she was always fighting a lost cause it seemed, with her jockey rather precariously perched.

She rallied to such good effect that she was flying home in third, not much more than a length behind the John Best-trained Stone Of Folca. Stone of Folca won the five-furlong sprint in a time of 53.69 seconds, then and still a record for an electronically timed five-furlong race. How close must Catfish have gone to being the world record holder!

Coincidentally, I was with Raymond and his long-time right-hand man Steve Gilbey on Friday celebrating Steve’s landmark 70th birthday. He certainly doesn’t look it! We love going to the Mandarin Kitchen next to Queensway Station and the food as ever was first class. The talk quickly turned to Constitution Hill’s comeback run in the Fighting Fifth Hurdle the following afternoon and, rather ungraciously, I suggested I thought he would fall.

Nicky Henderson has a wonderful record in the race with nine wins starting from 2001 with Landing Light. His second was Ray’s Punjabi in 2008 when the race was switched to Wetherby while Constitution Hill won it as a five-year-old in 2022, by 12 lengths from smart stable-companion Epatante.

That superb mare was again in second when Constitution Hill won the Christmas Hurdle by 17 lengths next time and had future champion State Man seven lengths adrift when winning his single Champion Hurdle in March 2023.

I was at a Cheltenham Preview on a Saturday evening in March in Central London this year, feeling obliged from the floor to suggest that I reckoned Constitution Hill was the best hurdler I’d ever seen, so why are we even discussing it? Lydia Hislop, one of the panel experts on the evening, was far less sure, citing that his jumping had become much less secure.

Of course, Constitution Hill fell when still in contention four from home on the big day and then State Man, poised for a follow-up to his 2024 success, fell at the last when five lengths clear. It was left to the mare Golden Ace, trained in the West Country by Jeremy Scott, to come through and seize the prize.

Rarely can a winner have been received with such scant praise, but Scott persevered, sending her over to Punchestown where she put in another brave show to follow home State Man for a further lucrative payday as Constitution Hill laboured home a remote fifth.

Runner-up when an odds-on shot and undercooked at Kempton on her return in the autumn, Golden Ace turned up once more in the Fighting Fifth with Jeremy going against the market, this time she was a 22/1 shot. Again, she benefited from others’ failings, Constitution Hill coming down as early as the second flight at Newcastle, and then his market rival, Dan Skelton’s The New Lion having to be rousted when narrowly ahead and falling two from home.

From there, it must be a cakewalk we reckoned for Willie Mullins’ hitherto unbeaten Anzadam, but after being brought with a smooth run by Paul Townend, he was a bit untidy at the last. Meanwhile, Golden Ace under Lorcan Williams, kept going in her usual fashion to win by one and a half lengths with the other outsider Nemean Lion getting within a neck of the runner-up at the line.

It’s hard to get rid of pre-conceptions but to say Golden Ace has been lucky in collecting both of her big prizes is to perhaps forget that this was her seventh win (plus three places) in her 11 starts over hurdles. The hurdles are there to jump and for some reason all the signs from Constitution Hill to his trainer that he was a different horse this year meant nowt. He seemingly restricts his errors to the racecourse.

I was surprised when he went to Punchestown last spring after the Champion Hurdle debacle. I would not be shocked if Nicky and owner Michael Buckley decided to finish him off now before that wonderful career is tarnished further. [Rumour is that he might run on the flat - Ed.]

Over at Newbury, it didn’t take long for Dan Skelton to wipe away the disappointment of The New Lion’s defeat in the Fighting Fifth. Two weeks earlier he had seen a long-laid plan come to fruition when his nine-year-old mare Panic Attack ran away with the Paddy Power Gold Cup over two and a half miles at Cheltenham.

Now, going up six furlongs in distance and carrying a 4lb penalty, she was theoretically 3lb well in after being raised 7lb for Cheltenham. With Dan’s brother Harry riding at Newcastle, 3lb claimer Tristan Durrell took over the reins and the mare skipped easily clear to pick up the £142k first prize. Come on Willie, wake up, Dan might soon be out of sight!

Just as keen on the cuisine of the Mandarin Kitchen are Maurice Manasseh and son David, who were both in Ireland yesterday for the comeback run back over hurdles of part-owner David’s Ballyburn, whose season over fences proved such an anti-climax last winter.

He returned for the Mullins team in the Hatton’s Grace Hurdle and although he didn’t quite prevent previous dual winner Teahupoo’s getting home for the hat-trick, in another stride he would have done. David can look forward to another Cheltenham Festival win, this time in the three-mile championship! He is only a 2/1 shot, but on the day that might look generous.

- TS

Other Recent Posts by This Author:

• Monday Musings: A Bit of a Joke…
• Monday Musings: Early Payout for Skelton
• Monday Musings: Top Jockeys
• Monday Musings: On Legacies…
• Monday Musings: Things Just Grand in Yorkshire