Racing Insights, Tuesday 26/03/24

GREEN is good (33% or better win rate) – worth 3 points
AMBER is quite good (16-32% win rate) – worth 1 point
RED is not so good (0-15% win rate) – worth -1 points
GREY means there is no available data for that factor - worth 0 points

The final column, ‘Score’, is the sum of the previous five ‘colour’ columns, with 15 being an all green profile, and 9 being the lowest score appearing on this report.

HINT: The best bets are not necessarily the highest scores. Rather, they are often the biggest difference between a Shortlist horse and the ‘best of the rest’ in that race.

N.B. Shortlist selections are unlikely to make a profit, at SP at least, to blind backing. Our recommendation has always been that The Shortlist should be a starting point rather than an end in itself. That said, it continues to highlight horses whose chance is better than recent form and its odds might imply.

Unfortunately, my fairly restrictive settings (you get to choose your own) have generated no qualifiers, but as ever, the daily feature is complemented by a selection of fully functional racecards opened up to all readers and for Tuesday they cover the following...

• 4.20 Taunton
• 5.45 Southwell
• 7.30 Dundalk
• 7.45 Southwell

...the best of which (on paper, at least) looks like being the 4.20 Taunton, a 6-runner, Class 3, 4yo+ handicap hurdle on good to soft ground over what will be a shade beyond 2m1f after rail movements...

My initial thoughts were that this might be quite competitive despite the small field with only top-weights Wolf Prince and Manor Park looking like they might struggle, but let's take a closer look at the whole field...

WOLF PRINCE made the frame in three consecutive races in the summer of 2022, but has disappointed in two runs this season after taking nearly 18 months off. Now without a win in 14 races since mid-October 2021, it's hard to see him landing this one, although he has won at both 2m and 2m2f.

MANOR PARK drops a class here as he returns from eight months off the track, during which time he has moved yards. he did win two starts ago at this class/trip at Newton Abbot back in July 2023, but flopped next/last time out a fortnight later at Market Rasen and a watching brief is advised here, even if he is 4 from 12 at 2m1f.

CELTIC ART has won over 2m in the past and is 3 from 5 on good to soft ground, so won't want any more rain to fall here. He was a winner in both January & February last year and again in November, but with three indifferent runs in between. Since then, he has run poorly on a couple of occasions, but looked like coming back into a bit of form a 4-length third of none over this course and distance five weeks ago.

AMELIA'S DANCE is a bit of an enigma, she loves it here with three of her four career wins coming over course and distance, but she's only 4 from 34 overall and has no win since scoring over track and trip in December 2022. She has been beaten eleven times since then, but has been the runner-up in each of her last three outings and in five of her last six, so she wouldn't be winning out of turn. Sadly her run of near misses means she's still 10lbs higher than her last winning mark and she's up a class today.

TOONAGH WARRIOR is much less experienced (just 11 starts) than the four runners above (who have raced 30+ times each), but has gone well since starting hurdling last September, finishing 321264 in six starts. The 6th place can be excused, as he'd stepped from 1m7½f to 2m4f, but his other four defeats at 1m7½f-2m were by an average of less than five lengths and he's eased 2lbs here today, but he is up one class.

HARA KIRI comes here on a hat-trick but will have to contend with stepping up two classes. He has won his last couple by narrow margins and his last run was littered with errors and he'll probably not get away with them at this level. That said, going and trip are both fine for him and he has only failed to make the frame twice in nine starts. He's also up 3lbs here, so will definitely need to work a bit harder today.

And Instant Expert confirms that Amelia's Dance has found wins hard to come by...

...on good to soft (1 from 9) and at Class 3 (0 from 9), but that she loves it here (3/8 and 3/6 over C&D), whilst Manor Park has also struggled at the going, class, and course. The trip shouldn't be an issue for most of these, but despite a smattering of 'green', there's no absolute standout on the win stats. That said, the field only has a combined strike rate of 13.8% (24 from 174), so we shouldn't have expected much more. Hopefully, we'll glean a little bit extra from the place stats...

...where Celtic Art is probably the pick of the pack, but Amelia's Dance looks more of a contender with some solid numbers from a decent sample size of races. Manor Park still looks out of his depth here and if he runs like he normally does, then he's going to be playing catchup later in the race too...

...which might leave him adrift as there might well be plenty of early pace. Celtic Art likes to get on with things, as does Wolf Prince, whilst Amelia's Dance was only headed deep into the final furlong last time out and it's those runners on the front end who tend to fare best in these contests...

Summary

Having looked at the race again, it's every bit as competitive as I thought it might be and you could easily make a case for four of them and the 5pm market seems to reflect this...

I'm not seeing a great deal of value in that price about Hara Kiri if truth be told, as he'll need considerable improvement if he's to complete the hat-trick. I don't think I'll even place a bet in this one (which is perfectly fine/acceptable, of course), but the one I probably would have gone with would be Celtic Art. He's no standout here, but ticks a few boxes.

Amelia's Dance will give her usual gutsy Taunton showing, but she's out of form and too high in the weights, so Toonagh Warrior might be the 'surprise package' here. Could be worth watching with a cup of tea, though, even if I've no cash down.